Inflammatory rhetoric is a threat to our democracy

Anyone who thinks domestic military occupation only happens in foreign countries ought to compare Caradonna's proposal to dispatch the Canadian military across downtown cores to Trump's executive order deploying the National Guard in Washington DC.

Remember when Jeremy Caradonna appealed to the Prime Minister to dispatch the military in downtown cores across the country in order to address the homelessness crisis?

This was on July 18 2024, during the Committee of the Whole meeting, in a discussion over a motion to end daytime sheltering, which of course revolved solely around enforcement.

Caradonna then made the following intervention [03:54:35]:

“In fact I’d like to make a personal appeal to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to consider working with the Department of National Defence to direct Canadian peacekeepers, Canadian peacekeepers, to organise a domestic humanitarian mission, not only to Victoria’s downtown core but all the downtown cores, affected by homelessness, mental health, and addiction. This is a humanitarian crisis, and Canadian peacekeepers are well-trained in dealing with humanitarian crises. It’s just that the difference here is that it is a domestic issue, not a foreign one.”

Excerpt from the July 18 2024 Committee of the Whole meeting.

However sugarcoated, this was a call to dispatch the military on domestic soil countrywide to carry out a mission they are most ill-suited for. Already it is considered common sense that the homeless population is particularly vulnerable to interaction with the police, so imagine how much worse it would be if forces trained to fight the Taliban in Afghanistan were sent to address homelessness, mental health, and addiction—for which by the way they have no training whatsoever.

Caradonna goes on with the delusion that the military can build modular housing in a matter of days, and that in the meantime the unhoused could be warehoused at the Bay Street Armoury for triage. That he pitched the idea around the time Premier David Eby announced the Surrey Pretrial Centre would be repurposed for involuntary care for mental health and addiction leaves no doubt about the intent behind the proposal, especially since the armoury has indeed the looks of a prison. Furthermore, he made it clear that he wanted the unhoused relocated to federal land, which is blatantly unconstitutional.

Anyone who would dismiss this warning as hysterical ought to have a look at the Housing Not Handcuffs webinar on the first year of Trump’s executive order unleashing the National Guard on the homeless population of Washington DC with the exact same mission.

To those of you who don’t have time to watch, here’s the TLDR version: Trump’s executive order didn’t solve anything, it made things even worse while normalizing a practice verboten in a healthy democratic society, with the consequences that we know.

Seriously, let that sink in for a second: one of our sitting council members made a proposal to address homelessness so unhinged that it follows Trump’s playbook to the letter. This should have sent a chill down every concerned citizen’s spine, as it did mine when I attended the council meeting, yet hardly anyone batted an eyelid even though it was reported by the mainstream media.

Inflammatory rhetoric is a most insidious threat to the rule of law and the rights we all take for granted, and dressing it as benevolence only adds insult to injury. Think about this as you head to the polls this week, because our democracy is at stake.


Discover more from Martin Girard for Victoria Municipal Council!

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.